Fortunately, scepticism regarding the ideology of Islam isn’t confined to the usual right-wing suspects. It’s a subject on which the rhetoric of, say, Melanie Phillips, James Delingpole and Douglas Murray is matched by that of several prominent left-wing commentators. For instance, Rod Liddle today published an article in The Spectator, entitled: “Here’s everything Islamophobic that I have to say, all at once” (read it here), in direct response to Miliband’s disgusting plan to further erode free speech. Liddle disappointed me recently by writing another article entitled: ‘Call me insane, but I’m voting Labour” which prompted his wife, among many others, to confirm that he was indeed insane, and to point out that Miliband’s dhimmitudinal new law would result in her husband being banged up for his comments on what he considers “an illiberal, vindictive and frankly fascistic creed.” Enjoy his article now, because such writings will be banned if Labour get in.
When it comes to writing about Islam and, in particular, his fellow-leftists’ cringing response to it, Nick Cohen is without equal. His genuinely brave 2007 book, What’s Left? – an examination of poisonous modern left-wing beliefs and attitudes – reminded me of similar attacks by George Orwell on his own side in the '30s and '40s. Earlier this week, Cohen wrote a truly magnificent article – also in The Spectator – entitled “Charlie Hebdo: the literary indulgence of murder”, in which he expresses righteous outrage at the writers who tried to stop PEN, an organisation whose aim is to defend free speech for writers, honouring Charlie Hebdo. The article is worth reading in its entirety (here), but this will give you a flavour:
They not only go along with the terrorists from the religious ultra-right but with every state that uses Islam to maintain its power. They can show no solidarity with gays in Iran, bloggers in Saudi Arabia and persecuted women and religious minorities across the Middle East, who must fight theocracy. They have no understanding that enemies of Charlie Hebdo are also the enemies of liberal Muslims and ex-Muslims in the West. In the battle between the two, they have in their stupidity and malice allied with the wrong side.This latest revolt against freedom by Western intellectuals was originally mounted last week by six deluded cowards (or “pussies” as Salman Rushdie termed them), but has since swelled to include another 29 gutless dhimmi scribblers – all of whom deserve our undying contempt. They all signed a letter to PEN earlier this week. The following paragraph almost made me throw up:
PEN is an essential organization in the global battle for freedom of expression. It is therefore disheartening to see that PEN America has chosen to honor the work and mission of Charlie Hebdo above those who not only exemplify the principles of free expression, but whose courage, even when provocative and discomfiting, has also been pointedly exercised for the good of humanity.If they feel that strongly about it, perhaps these pantywaist hand-wringers could be persuaded to attend an alternative event honouring those very writers “whose courage, even when provocative and discomfiting, has also been pointedly exercised for the good of humanity” and whom PEN has apparently so cruelly ignored. To give these infinitely compassionate humanitarians an opportunity to demonstrate their own immense reserves of courage, perhaps they should hold their enlightened event in one of those parts of the Middle East currently under the control of the Islamic murderers whose feelings they seem so keen to protect. (As a sign of respect, perhaps they could all join in the joyous shout of "Allahu Akbar" as their ravening hosts start hacking through their necks with a variety of sharp-edged weapons.)
Here is the full list of the whining bed-wetters who signed a letter to PEN in protest at the award. Shame on all their sorry little cultural Marxist arses:
Chris Abani
Russell Banks
Peter Carey
Teju Cole
Junot Díaz
Deborah Eisenberg
Eve Ensler
Nell Freudenberger
Keith Gessen
Francisco Goldman
Edward Hoagland
Nancy Kricorian
Amitava Kumar
Rachel Kushner
Zachary Lazar
Patrick McGrath
Rick Moody
Lorrie Moore
Joyce Carol Oates
Michael Ondaatje
Raj Patel
Francine Prose
Sarah Schulman
Taiye Selasi
Kamila Shamsie
Wallace Shawn
Charles Simic
Rebecca Solnit
Linda Spalding
Scott Spencer
Chase Twichell
Eliot Weinberger
Jon Wiener
Dave Zirin
I am ashamed to say that I have only heard of two people on the PEN list and those only because they made terrible films of two of their respective novels [ Carey's "Oscar and Lucinda" and Ondaatje's "The English Patient"] and both of those "starred" dead-beat actor Ralph Fiennes which is usually the kiss of death [see also Nighy and Firth]. Wiener is an interesting name.
ReplyDelete