There's recently been a spate of lists of classic films all children should see (here's one, and here's another). These are usually compiled with the desire to give children a decent grounding in movie history, and I certainly have no objection to that - I really can't tell you how important movies were to me growing up. But I’ve decided to come over all moralistic and compile a list based entirely on the life lessons the films teach.I was partly motivated by seeing Avatar two years and wondering just how many truly dreadful lessons children would take away from it: America is always wrong, technology is always evil, living in forests close to nature invariably makes you noble, and the powerful are always oppressors. What a bunch of crap!
I realise many of the moral lessons I’ve identified in my chosen films will sound trite – but, then, the truth often tends to. So, in no particular order:
Zulu – patriotism, bravery, courage, steadfastness, sacrifice and respecting your enemy are to be admired, and just because a cause is hopeless doesn’t mean you should abandon it.
High Noon – the people you rely on will sometimes prove wanting: occasionally, you really will have to go it alone, and it doesn’t always end badly
It's A Wonderful Life – as long as you’re not an evil person, no matter how bad things seem, the world really wouldn’t be a better place without you
It Happened One Night – charm and humour will get you a long way: and there are times when turning down rewards is the right thing to do
Night of The Hunter – there's evil in the world and monsters exist: be on your guard (and, if possible, seek the help of a tiny old Christian lady with a gun)
The Grapes of Wrath – people’s misfortunes are not always their fault, and ordinary folk are often the most decent of all
Groundhog Day – life tends to offer us more than one chance to get it right
On The Waterfront – don't do wickeds things just because your friends tell you to
Doctor Zhivago – when people who're sure they're right set about creating utopias, they always turn out to be living hells
Henry V – if you're ever given the chance to lead, this is how you do it (and whenever you get a chance to duff up the French, take it!)
The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance – if you stand up to bullies, help will usually arrive (although you can't always guarantee it'll be in the form of John Wayne with a rifle)
Invasion of the Bodysnatchers – beware of the herd mentality: we were born to be different
I realise that morality isn’t gender-specific, but I’ve come up with a list of films for boys simply on the basis that I used to be one, and I don’t have any daughters – I’ll leave it to others better qualified than I to come up with a suitable list for girls.


What a great list. At least half of them are as well directed to girls as to boys. I would add-
ReplyDeleteHue and Cry - that's really what our great city looked like after your grandparents' generation had given up their best years. Think about what it must have been like.
The Lady Vanishes - don't back down when men try to patronise you into denying what you know you have sen
Little Women - follow your muse and don't trust your younger sister
Little Mermaid - sometimes your father's work requires him to leave the room to attend to urgent matters.
The Wind That Shakes The Barley - get your history from books, not films
The Godfather - sometimes you can take family loyalty too far
Other people's lists of films are always fascinating. My own modest contribution:
ReplyDelete"M" [Fritz Lang] - avoid talking to strangers who look like Peter Lorre.
"Richard III" [L. Olivier] - don't be hurtful to your uncle even if he looks odd.
"Lost Week End", "Scarface", "Man with the Golden Arm" - avoid excess.
"Wizard of Oz" - don't watch this in a cinema. There are some strange people about. [Also, "Wilde" with Stephen Fry].
"Seventh Seal" [I. Bergmann] - avoid playing chess with bald men in black cloaks and pancake make-up on beaches.
"That Hamilton Woman", "Master and Commander", "Sink the Bismarck" [inter alia] - don't dick with the Royal Navy.
"Reach for the Sky" - legless people can be great war heroes.
"War&Peace" [King Vidor], "The Charge of the Light Brigade" [Tony Richardson]& "Stalingrad"[ Joseph Vilsmaier] - never attack Russia. It always ends in tears.
"I'm alright, Jack" [inter alia] - it is tragic when a country loses its ability to produce very funny films. Many films from the 50s and early 60s show true genius. Where are you now, Dr Gaston Grimsdyke?
"Brighton Rock" & "10 Rillington Place" -even very nice guys like Lord Onions can turn very nasty. Everybody has a side. [see Henry Fonda in "Once upon a time in the West". No more Mr Nice Guy].
Based on my childhood experience the two films that children should not see are "House of Wax" [Vincent Price, 1953] and "Them!" [lots of big ants, 1954]. I saw them when I was around eight years old and had serious nightmares for weeks afterwards. The original "Cape Fear" [1962] ditto.
Another great list, to add to which:-
ReplyDeleteDays of Wine and Roses/Lost Weekend- if you're totally legless, not being a war hero is probably the least of your problems
When an East Sussex pub re-named itself "The Douglas Bader" the local rag ran the head-line "Pub named after legless pilot".
ReplyDeleteI just stuck "legless war hero" into Googke and was amazed by how many kosher results there were - and it's not just foreign papers: the Mirror and the Telegraph, among others, use the phrase often. Are we just horribly insensitive, or isn't "legless" a synonym for "pissed" any longer?
ReplyDeleteAnd thanks for your very interesting lists, by the way - I'll be doing one of films boys shouldn't be encouraged to watch soon.
ReplyDelete"Master and Commander" is often near the top of lists of top Conservative and Right-Wing films: it seems to be the modern equivalent of "Zulu", mainly because it's big on patriotism, loyalty, leadership, discipline and courage, while containing nary a hint of criticism of Britain's disgraceful imperialistic past.
A friend leant me a DVD of "Hue and Cry", which I'd never seen, a couple of years ago. Fascinating film. Critics bang on about "Rome - Open City" and "The Naked City" using actual locations, but "Hue and Cry" doesn't often get mentioned in the same breath, for some odd reason. I was reminded of it when reading the obituary of actor Harry Fowler last week.